After the most recent Fed rate hike, where are mortgage rates headed?

OUR ACTIONS. SOLEDAD: LANCE FREEMAN IS A SCHOLAR OF URBAN HOUSING AND GENTRIFICATION. HE IS A PROFESSOR OF CITY AND REGIONAL PLANNING, AND SOCIOLOGY AT THE UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA. PROFESSOR FREEMAN, THANK YOU FOR TALKING WITH ME. SO, THE WOMAN IN THAT PIECE, FATIMA LASTER, WANTED TO RECLAIM AND PRESERVE HER NEIGHBORHOOD FOR THE PEOPLE WHO ARE LIVING THERE. SO, I’D LIKE YOU TO WALK US THROUGH WHAT ARE THE FORCES THAT SHE’S FIGHTING AGAINST WHEN IT COMES TO GENTRIFICATION. PROFESSOR FREEMAN: QUITE OFTEN WHAT’S HAPPENING IS WHAT WE’RE SEEING IS A TENSION BETWEEN A HOME COMMUNITY, THE SENTIMENTAL VALUES THAT PEOPLE ATTACH TO WHERE THEY LIVE, AND MARKET FORCES. GENTRIFICATION IS OFTENTIMES ASSOCIATED WITH INCREASED INVESTMENT. AND WITH THAT, THAT COULD CREATE CHANGES IN HOUSING PRICES, CHANGES IN THE RETAIL LANDSCAPE. AND THAT CAN CLASH WITH THE SENTIMENTAL VALUES, THE SENSE OF COMMUNITY THAT PEOPLE ATTACH TO THEIR PLACES. SOLEDAD: I THINK IT’S REALLY TRUE HOW OUTSIDERS, WHEN THEY COME INTO COMMUNITIES THAT ARE BEING GENTRIFIED, THEY TALK ABOUT ALL THAT’S BEING GAINED. TALK ABOUT A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT WHAT’S LOST. PROFESSOR FREEMAN: IT COULD MEAN A LOSS OF RELATIONSHIPS. YOU COULD LOSE YOUR FRIENDS. SOMETIMES PEOPLE LIVE IN THE SAME NEIGHBORHOOD AS A CLOSE FAMILY MEMBER, SO THEY COULD BE LOSING MEMBERS OF THEIR FAMILY. IT COULD BE A LOCAL CHURCH, FOR EXAMPLE, IF MANY OF THE CONGREGATION, MOVE AWAY FROM A NEIGHBORHOOD, THE CHURCH ITSELF MIGHT NOT BE ABLE TO SURVIVE. SOLEDAD: I ALWAYS WONDER, CAN YOU HAVE THE GOOD THINGS WITHOUT SORT OF DISPLACING ALL THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE TO LEAVE AND CAN’T GET THE BENEFIT OF THOSE GOOD THINGS? PROFESSOR FREEMAN: I THINK YOU NEED TO PUT IN PLACE MECHANISMS THAT ALLOW, SAY, FOR EXAMPLE, LOW-INCOME HOUSEHOLDS TO CONTINUE TO MOVE INTO A GENTRIFYING NEIGHBORHOOD. THAT COULD BE DONE, FOR EXAMPLE, THROUGH INCLUSIONARY ZONING, WHEREBY NEW HOUSING THAT IS BUILT INCLUDES BOTH MARKET RATE HOUSING, BUT THEN ALSO AN AFFORDABLE HOUSING COMPONENT. YOU CAN ALSO DO THINGS LIKE AFFORDABLE HOMEOWNERSHIP PROGRAMS. THIS GIVES LOW INCOME AND MODERATE-INCOME HOUSEHOLDS AN OPPORTUNITY TO ACQUIRE A STAKE IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD SO THAT AS PROPERTY VALUES RISE, AS WEALTH IS CREATED, PEOPLE WHO LIVE IN THE COMMUNITY HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THAT. SOLEDAD: PROFESSOR LANCE FREEMA

The Federal Reserve hiked its benchmark lending rate this week for the seventh time this year, capping a year of intense pressure on the housing market that pushed mortgage rates above 7% for the first time since 2002.But now that the Fed has signaled a softer approach to cooling the economy instead of rolling out bumper rate hikes, potential home buyers are left to wonder: Will mortgage rates come back down? Or have buyers missed their chance?No one knows exactly where mortgage rates will go in the months ahead. But most experts agree that we have seen the end of 3% mortgages for some time.Mortgage rates have run up so far and so fast this year that many would-be homebuyers can no longer afford to buy a home. At the end of 2022, when rates were at 3%, few predicted that just a year later rates around this week’s 6.33% would come as a relief, having dropped from over 7%.After starting the year at an average 3.22%, according to Freddie Mac, the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage took off last spring as the Federal Reserve embarked on a historic campaign to battle decades-high inflation by raising interest rates. By fall, mortgage rates had more than doubled, eventually topping 7% in October. Rates have receded slightly in recent weeks, but loans are still expensive �� especially compared to the historically low rates buyers were getting during the pandemic.Home shoppers have watched their buying power evaporate, with higher rates adding hundreds of dollars onto what they would pay each month.High mortgage rates remain the primary impediment to home buying, according to a recent buyer and seller sentiment survey conducted by Fannie Mae. Homebuying and home-selling sentiment are both significantly lower than they were last year.Based on the survey, people in the real estate market continue to expect mortgage rates to rise but home prices to decline, said Doug Duncan, Fannie Mae senior vice president and chief economist.He said he expects mortgage demand to be dampened by affordability challenges, while “homeowners with significantly lower-than-current mortgage rates may be discouraged from listing their property and potentially taking on a new, much higher mortgage rate.”Is this the new normal?While the Fed’s rate hikes are expected to continue, many analysts anticipate they will be smaller than the recent bout of three-quarter-point hikes and will start to taper off as inflation starts to cool, which should mean mortgage rates will likely come down too.The Fed does not set the interest rates borrowers pay on mortgages directly. But its actions influence them. Mortgage rates tend to track the yield on 10-year US Treasury bonds, which move based on a combination of anticipation about the Fed’s actions, what the Fed actually does and investors�� reactions. When Treasury yields go up, so do mortgage rates; when they go down, mortgage rates tend to follow.If rates do drop, just how low will they go?“If inflation continues to decelerate over the next several months, mortgage rates will likely stabilize below 7%,�� said Nadia Evangelou, senior economist and director of forecasting at the National Association of Realtors. “That’s still double the previous year’s rate, but it’s better than an 8% rate, which is the historical average for the 30-year fixed mortgage.”Looking ahead, Melissa Cohn, regional vice president at William Raveis Mortgage, said buyers should expect rates to level off in 2023 around where they were in the years before the pandemic �� around 4% or 5%.“We had an active and healthy real estate market then,�� she said.But Cohn said she does not expect a “meaningful�� decline in mortgage rates until the third or fourth quarter of 2023. “Mortgage rates will drop a bit in December, we’ll see a brief flurry of activity, but there are likely to be more increases in the new year.”And don’t expect to see rates drop at the same speed at which they rose this year, she said.“We have to remember mortgage rates come down much slower than they go up,�� said Cohn. “Banks will want to see proof that rates are meaningfully coming down and not a one-shot wonder.”The weekly swings in mortgage rates this year have been about three times the size of those seen in a typical year, said Danielle Hale, chief economist at Realtor.com. The Fed’s extra-large rate hikes aren’t the only thing causing that.Economic uncertainty is creating a larger gap or “spread�� between the 10-year Treasury yield and mortgage rates. Typically, mortgage rates are about two percentage points above the 10-year Treasury yield, but recently the gap has been wider.The main driver of the widening spread is greater interest rate risk, according to a recent report from the Urban Institute.“The uncertainty about the effects of Fed policy to date and about the trajectory of future policy has resulted in large movements in interest rates,�� wrote Laurie Goodman and Michael Neal, the report’s authors.Consumer mortgages are packaged and sold off to investors. The higher myeortgage rates are, the more money investors can make. But as rates fall, more homeowners will choose to prepay their mortgages or refinance, making the loans less attractive to investors.“Volatility increases the level of mortgage rates, compared to Treasury rates, because of the prepayment option,�� said Chester Spatt, professor of finance at Carnegie Mellon University’s Tepper School of Business. “If you’re in a new loan at 7% and rates go to 6%, you may choose to prepay and refinance into a lower rate.”It is abnormal to have such a large spread, said Lawrence Yun, chief economist for NAR, adding that other times when the spread was wider were during the 2008 financial crisis and the early days of the pandemic.“Hopefully this large spread will dissipate by the spring home buying season,�� he said. “If so, maybe buyers will face mortgage rates in the 5’s.”What buyers can expectLisa Sturtevant, chief economist at Bright MLS, a multiple listing service in the mid-Atlantic region, also expects mortgage rates to fall further in 2023, but she doesn’t expect them to drop quickly.“We were in unprecedented territory with rates under 3%,�� she said. “There is no reason to suggest we will be back there. But they will be down from where we’ve been.”“Housing market activity will continue to be relatively sluggish �� even if mortgage rates do begin to come down �� since so many existing homeowners are locked into sub-3% loans and will still not be eager to move into a higher rate,�� she said.As a result, the inventory of available homes for sale will remain tight into 2023. In many markets this could guard against prices dropping by a significant amount.“Prospective buyers may be tempted to try to ‘time�� rates to jump into the market when rates dip,�� she said. “But timing rates is difficult.”Instead, would-be buyers should shop around, getting quotes from multiple lenders, including different types like a large national bank, an online lender or a community bank or credit union.“There is a lot of variability in rates, terms, and mortgage products in this changing market,�� Sturtevant said. “It is more important than ever that buyers compare offers from different lenders to find the financing that works best for them.��

WASHINGTON —

But now that the Fed has signaled a softer approach to cooling the economy instead of rolling out bumper rate hikes, potential home buyers are left to wonder: Will mortgage rates come back down? Or have buyers missed their chance?

No one knows exactly where mortgage rates will go in the months ahead. But most experts agree that we have seen the end of 3% mortgages for some time.

Mortgage rates have run up so far and so fast this year that many would-be homebuyers can no longer afford to buy a home. At the end of 2022, when rates were at 3%, few predicted that just a year later rates around this week’s 6.33% would come as a relief, having dropped from over 7%.

After starting the year at an average 3.22%, according to Freddie Mac, the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage took off last spring as the Federal Reserve embarked on a historic campaign to battle decades-high inflation by raising interest rates. By fall, mortgage rates had more than doubled, eventually topping 7% in October. Rates have receded slightly in recent weeks, but loans are still expensive �� especially compared to the historically low rates buyers were getting during the pandemic.

Home shoppers have watched their buying power evaporate, with higher rates adding hundreds of dollars onto what they would pay each month.

High mortgage rates remain the primary impediment to home buying, according to a recent buyer and seller sentiment survey conducted by Fannie Mae. Homebuying and home-selling sentiment are both significantly lower than they were last year.

Based on the survey, people in the real estate market continue to expect mortgage rates to rise but home prices to decline, said Doug Duncan, Fannie Mae senior vice president and chief economist.

He said he expects mortgage demand to be dampened by affordability challenges, while “homeowners with significantly lower-than-current mortgage rates may be discouraged from listing their property and potentially taking on a new, much higher mortgage rate.��

Is this the new normal?

While the Fed’s rate hikes are expected to continue, many analysts anticipate they will be smaller than the recent bout of three-quarter-point hikes and as inflation starts to cool, which should mean mortgage rates will likely come down too.

The Fed does not set the interest rates borrowers pay on mortgages directly. But its actions influence them. Mortgage rates tend to track the yield on 10-year US Treasury bonds, which move based on a combination of anticipation about the Fed’s actions, what the Fed actually does and investors�� reactions. When Treasury yields go up, so do mortgage rates; when they go down, mortgage rates tend to follow.

If rates do drop, just how low will they go?

“If inflation continues to decelerate over the next several months, mortgage rates will likely stabilize below 7%,�� said Nadia Evangelou, senior economist and director of forecasting at the National Association of Realtors. “That’s still double the previous year’s rate, but it’s better than an 8% rate, which is the historical average for the 30-year fixed mortgage.��

Looking ahead, Melissa Cohn, regional vice president at William Raveis Mortgage, said buyers should expect rates to level off in 2023 around where they were in the years before the pandemic �� around 4% or 5%.

“We had an active and healthy real estate market then,�� she said.

But Cohn said she does not expect a “meaningful�� decline in mortgage rates until the third or fourth quarter of 2023. “Mortgage rates will drop a bit in December, we’ll see a brief flurry of activity, but there are likely to be more increases in the new year.��

And don’t expect to see rates drop at the same speed at which they rose this year, she said.

“We have to remember mortgage rates come down much slower than they go up,�� said Cohn. “Banks will want to see proof that rates are meaningfully coming down and not a one-shot wonder.��

The weekly swings in mortgage rates this year have been about three times the size of those seen in a typical year, said Danielle Hale, chief economist at Realtor.com. The aren’t the only thing causing that.

Economic uncertainty is creating a larger gap or “spread�� between the 10-year Treasury yield and mortgage rates. Typically, mortgage rates are about two percentage points above the 10-year Treasury yield, but recently the gap has been wider.

The main driver of the widening spread is greater interest rate risk, according to a from the Urban Institute.

“The uncertainty about the effects of Fed policy to date and about the trajectory of future policy has resulted in large movements in interest rates,�� wrote Laurie Goodman and Michael Neal, the report’s authors.

Consumer mortgages are packaged and sold off to investors. The higher myeortgage rates are, the more money investors can make. But as rates fall, more homeowners will choose to prepay their mortgages or refinance, making the loans less attractive to investors.

“Volatility increases the level of mortgage rates, compared to Treasury rates, because of the prepayment option,�� said Chester Spatt, professor of finance at Carnegie Mellon University’s Tepper School of Business. “If you’re in a new loan at 7% and rates go to 6%, you may choose to prepay and refinance into a lower rate.��

It is abnormal to have such a large spread, said Lawrence Yun, chief economist for NAR, adding that other times when the spread was wider were during the 2008 financial crisis and the early days of the pandemic.

“Hopefully this large spread will dissipate by the spring home buying season,�� he said. “If so, maybe buyers will face mortgage rates in the 5’s.��

What buyers can expect

Lisa Sturtevant, chief economist at Bright MLS, a multiple listing service in the mid-Atlantic region, also expects mortgage rates to fall further in 2023, but she doesn’t expect them to drop quickly.

“We were in unprecedented territory with rates under 3%,�� she said. “There is no reason to suggest we will be back there. But they will be down from where we’ve been.��

“Housing market activity will continue to be relatively sluggish �� even if mortgage rates do begin to come down �� since so many existing homeowners are locked into sub-3% loans and will still not be eager to move into a higher rate,�� she said.

As a result, the inventory of available homes for sale will remain tight into 2023. In many markets this could guard against prices dropping by a significant amount.

“Prospective buyers may be tempted to try to ‘time�� rates to jump into the market when rates dip,�� she said. “But timing rates is difficult.��

Instead, would-be buyers should shop around, getting quotes from multiple lenders, including different types like a large national bank, an online lender or a community bank or credit union.

“There is a lot of variability in rates, terms, and mortgage products in this changing market,�� Sturtevant said. “It is more important than ever that buyers compare offers from different lenders to find the financing that works best for them.��

��������